Monday, August 6, 2012

Persepolis


While inspecting the cover of the book, I assume that the characters on the front are a family. I expect that these characters are the subjects of the novel and that the story will be based around their relationships.
            Before reading this book, I knew nothing about it or the movie. I had never heard of either. I have never read a graphic novel before this class and I am really behind on movies. I also have never heard of the word “Persepolis” so I went on google and this is what I got:

Random House Webster's College Dictionary
Per•sep•o•lispərˈsɛp ə lɪs(n.)
An ancient capital of Persia: its ruins are near Shiraz in SW Iran.
Category: Ancient History, Archaeology, Geography (places)

The Nuttall Encyclopedia
Persepolis

The ancient capital of Persia, represented now by its ruins, which stand 25 m. from the NW. shores of Lake Niris, on the banks of the Murghab River, though in its palmy days it was described as "the Glory of the East."


map-Iran.jpg

            After I understood the title, I thought about my impressions of Islam and gender. I am extremely ignorant with religion in general because I was raised as having religion optional. I was never pressed to go to church, pray or even learn about the history of religion whether it be Christianity, Judaism, or Islamic. I had one class in middle school where I learned the basics of these three religions. When I think of Islam and woman I think of oppression. I know that the woman have to be covered from head to toe in a burqa only allowing the eyes to be visible in order to cover a woman’s body and sexuality. I also think that woman have less freedom then men and if a woman is married then she has to do what is told by her husband.
            I know even less about Christianity and gender. When I think about the difference between men and woman in this religion I just think about how all the main people in the bible are men. God is seen as a male figure, Jesus was a man and I’m almost positive all of the prophets were all male. If I recall correctly the woman in the Bible are the first to give in to temptation (Eve) and to bear children (Mary). I also know that when two people get married the significance of having the woman’s father walk her down the isle is for the father to give his daughters hand (I take it as giving her daughter) to the new man in her life, her husband. I’m not sure if that is classified as a Christian tradition but I see it as woman are property and that the men in our lives own/control us. Which in the end, is how my impression of the Islamic religion is.

My knowledge of Iran:
  The country is in the Middle East
·      Iran use to be known as Persia, (and if I am recalling my high school military history class correctly) the Persian army back in the 500 BCE era was extremely powerful and controlled a lot of the countries/area then.
·      Surrounded by Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan.
·      Has a lot of oil

By looking at the pictures on the first and last page I am assuming that this book is about the life of a woman. The first page is a young girl who is wearing a veil and looks very unhappy. The last page looks like a departure. The women are still in veils but there are smiles, tears, hugs and what looks like goodbyes. I’m guessing the story is about a woman growing up and then saying goodbye to what she knows/is use to.


Thinking of the book as a memoir, with a focus on memory, truth, and representation:

            Knowing that Persepolis is a memoir makes it seem more believable to me than just another story about life in Iran. For me, it’s hard to understand certain things unless I was there to witness it or have someone tells me their own memory of the event. For example, textbooks are very hard for me to read and truly understand what is trying to be represented because to me they are just words. Put an actual story that happened along with the text, emotions, senses, feelings, actual conversations, etc. then I can put myself in the situation and envision the event or story myself. Satrapi does a good job allowing the reader to see, feel and really connect with her because she opens up and writes/draws how she saw life through her eyes. I found it really easy to sympathize, get angry, be happy, miss her family with her. I don’t get those feelings when I’m reading material that is so black and white like a textbook about Iran would.
            “Humor is the writer’s armor against the hard emotions” (William Zinsser). In Persepolis, Satrapi uses this thinking on page 266 when she leaves her old friend Kia. Satrapi writes “That day, I learned something essential: we can only feel sorry for ourselves when our misfortunes are still supportable…once this limit is crossed, the only way to bear the unbearable is to laugh at it.” To make Zinsser’s quote more general I would take out the word write and replace the word with humans. I say that because Satrapi is not making a joke out of Kia’s hardships through her writing, she is writing about how they enjoyed their time together, made jokes and laughed because that was all they could do. They could have sat there and felt sorry for Kia, complained about the politics of Iran, the war but all of that news is unbearable and the only way to live with it all is to make something bearable and for them its humor and laughter. On page 97, Satrapi writes “ Every situation offered an opportunity for laughs: like when we had to knit hoods for the soldiers…”. I don’t think at this point of the story Satrapi’s thoughts and emotions followed Zinsser’s philosophy. She is a child at this stage of the book and I got the feeling that at this age Satrapi was just annoyed with everything having to do with war/politics of Iran and just wanted to be a kid. Her and her friends mocked everything that they needed to take seriously because I think they were just extremely fed up with everything.
            In Persepolis, Satrapi tells many people’s stories besides her own because all of these stores relate to her own. All these stories keep showing that history is repeating itself over and over because there continues to be someone out there who is hungry enough for power and money that they will do anything to obtain them. Anoosh’s story of his uncle is about how he tried to revolt against the government of Iran at the time and like other’s similar to him, he met his destiny. The same death also found Anoosh for being associated with his uncle Fereydoon and following his beliefs. When Anoosh’s uncle was executed, Anoosh left the country and when Anoosh gets executed himself, Marjane leaves the country but for different reasons. Their stories are similar but for different reasons.
            The personal stories of individual citizens relates to the history of their nation by allowing a different perspective to be shown. A lot of people outside of Iran may think or Iranians as blood, power and money hungry or that the women are extremely conservative and fearful. This book shows that the civilians are normal people just like everyone else on the planet. This book also shows that some women can be very strong and question everything and don’t let conformity consume them because of fear.
            A hero that is memorable in Satrapi’s story is her uncle, Anoosh. What makes him heroic to Satrpi is how passionate he is about his beliefs and how he suffered in jail for his actions. Even though he believed in communism, was a communist and a maybe a Russian spy (unless that was a lie from the newspaper to look like his execution was justified) Marjane thought of him as a hero because he was a rebel and believed so much in his opinions.

images.jpg

Sunday, July 29, 2012

La Perdida

I was really annoyed with the main character Carla as I read La Perdida. She is someone who has no common sense and trusts strangers way too easily. Throughout the entire book she continued to make mistake after mistake. Carla actually reminds me of one of my old high school friends. My old friend had a horrible taste guys just like Carla. These guys would treat her awful and use her for what she was worth and while we continuously told her they were bad news and to get herself away from them, she would never listen. The relationship between Sylvia and Carla really reminded me of how my friendship was. Our friendship also ended the same as the characters did. She never took my advice, got in a bad situation and our friendship ended.

When I first read the beginning of La Perdida (pages 3-8) I was totally confused. I didn't understand who the characters were, where the story was taking place or even what was going on. After I finished the book, I went back and reread that section and I finally understood. Abel, the author, was showing us what Carla was doing with her life at the present time with some foreshadowing of what the story was going to get into with flashbacks. I like how Abel did this but I think this technique would have worked better if this story was a movie. Reading this flashback that Carla is having is just confusing for the first time reader. I think she should have put this section at the end of the book as an epilogue. Thats the way I had to read it when I finished to understand.

I really liked the title of the book. I found two similar translations: "The Lost" and "The Lost Woman." This fits the story perfectly because Carla is just a lost soul the entire book. I don't think she truly knows what she wants or who she is. It's like she wants to become an authentic Mexican but instead she is just wondering around Mexico City, making bad decisions, and pissing off everyone she meets. She doesn't feel at home in Mexico and then when she comes back to the U.S. she doesn't feel like that is home either because she is scared for her life.

In the end, I am not a fan of the book. I was angry with the main character the entire book and I just felt like the book didn't get anywhere. I also did not like the Spanish that was in the dialogue. There wasn't a translation for all of the Spanish and I understand that sometimes there isn't an English translation for some phrases but when that happened in the story it was hard to follow.


Monday, July 23, 2012

Post #1 - Fun Home

       As I began to read “Fun Home” by Alison Bechdel, I did not know what to expect. This is the first graphic novel that I have ever completed. What I first noticed was the use of the black and white graphics. I found throughout the novel that these illustrations were gloomy and sometimes dark. Within the entire book, none of the characters showed any kind of emotion in the illustrations. It is like the author did that on purpose to show that the characters all had some sort of mask on that covered who they really were. I thought the theme of this book was about discovery and understanding. In the story, Alison is uncovering her homosexuality, exploring it and also learning about her father as well. As I read, I actually felt bad for Alison. I felt like she had no support from her family (her parents mostly) and that she had to do this transformation on her own (for the most part). It wasn’t until the very last chapter when her father and her are driving to the movies when he finally seems like he cares some and opens up to his daughter. When I finished this book, I just felt kind of empty.  I felt sorry for Alison throughout the entire book. She ended up raising herself without the love and support of her parents. I found that I continued to become angry with Alison’s mother. She didn’t show any kind of sympathy or guidance when Alison began maturing and started to menstruate, she would tell Alison not to bother her when Alison was a young child and she seemed to only care about herself and her “acting” career.